It's More Important Than Ever To Call Out Developers For Egregious...

We're being limit tested, and I fear we're too okay with it all right now.

God, I am growing so weary of AI. Glints of human creation chipped away at with "just a loading screen" here, or "just a couple voicelines" there. Flaws and oddities that aren't the result of a person's error, but a computer that doesn't understand what or why it's wrong in the first place.

This year, it feels like studios have been limit testing exactly what they can get away with. Whether they can save a few pennies by getting a computer to whip up a character portrait, or a quick musical sting, without us lot at home kicking up too much of a fuss. The worst part? I fear it's working, and it's only going to get more egregious if we continue to wave off its (currently) limited use.

I myself am not absolved of this dismissive behaviour. I'm part of the problem. I've played several demos over the last couple of years that sport generative AI for its capsule image—a necessary component to put your game up on the Steam store, but one that ultimately isn't all that important to the likes of you and me.

I bought and played several hours of Liar's Bar, a game that utilises AI voices for its characters. Something that, at the time, I had excused as a byproduct of a dirt-cheap asset flip. One which just happened to be the right amount of stupid fun for a quick late-night post-booze endeavour with your Discord pals. A game where posts asking for the developer to use real voice acting are met with comments such as "SJW behaviour" and "Seethe."

There's this strange downward spiral where people go from brushing off AI's inclusion to actively rallying against people who call out its use. I have to wonder if it's because people don't exactly vibe with having the things they enjoy criticised for something that they themselves, deep down, don't approve of.

Just look at how divisive Arc Raiders has been. I haven't played it myself, but it has taken over the lives of just about every person in my friendship group. It's a game that also utilises AI voices—built upon real voice actors and with their contractual consent so that Embark doesn't need "to have someone come in every time [it creates] a new item for the game." Something that, for the most part, people seem happy to deal with even when things sound a little janky as a result.

As Wes wrote earlier this year, the game is emblematic of how muddy the whole thing is. Sure, it's not generative AI in the broadest sense, but it ultimately still

Source: PC Gamer